Ford Powerstroke Diesel Forum banner

Switching to 5W-40 Synthetic ?????

12K views 10 replies 9 participants last post by  thekroog  
#1 ·
I've got a 2007 6.0 Power Stroke with 500,000 miles on it now. The engine was never rebuilt and its always had 15W-40 since new. I always used the John Deere 15W-40 Plus-50II non synthetic oil and get great oil analysis reports. Shear is not an issue. I also have been using the Archoil additive the last 100,000 miles. I've been pondering switching to 5W-40 synthetic for the last year since its been out awhile now. Its cold most of the year where I'm at and not always convenient to plug the truck in. Anybody have bad results switching over to the 5W-40 in their 6.0? My worry is that 5W-40 is not as stable as the 15W-40 but I would like the benefit of the 5W-40 for cold starts. My truck doesn't burn oil but it seeps a little out around the oil pan gasket. I tow with the truck so 10W-30 is not an option.

I really love my 6.0 and have maintained it meticulously. I want to keep it running as long as I can and prolong having to drop 60-85K for a new 1-ton. I've switched oils in gas motors but never in diesels. I seem to get many different opinions; I don't want to mess up my engine after I've come this far with it.
 
#3 ·
IMO, there's honestly no reason not to switch to a good quality 5w-40 synthetic, especially in a cold climate. No matter the mileage. They run at the same viscosity when hot. I suspect you'll even notice slightly less injector noise with a 5w-40 synthetic. Rotella, Mobil 1, Valvoline and others all have very good options.
 
#4 ·
The Deere oil is over kill in a pickup truck, same for the other off road manufacturers (the Red and Blue guys)
the Rotella is a commercial grade oil, you would have to step up to Rimula to be equivalent to the Green, Red, and Blue oils
nothing wrong with running better oil, just the cost

The 5W-40 will help the truck start better, same for your heavy equipment
the Red guys(and I suspect the Green guys) have synthetic oil if your a mind to stick with those
a lot have used the Rotella T6 and had good luck with it in a truck
 
owns 2006 Ford F250 Lariat FX4
#5 ·
The Deere oil is over kill in a pickup truck, same for the other off road manufacturers (the Red and Blue guys)
the Rotella is a commercial grade oil, you would have to step up to Rimula to be equivalent to the Green, Red, and Blue oils
nothing wrong with running better oil, just the cost

The 5W-40 will help the truck start better, same for your heavy equipment
the Red guys(and I suspect the Green guys) have synthetic oil if your a mind to stick with those
a lot have used the Rotella T6 and had good luck with it in a truck
I like the Deere oil because its a superior product. Nothing works harder than a tractor out in a field on a hot day. I don't mind paying more for a better product. If I switch I'll go with the Deere 5W-40 or the Motorcraft I think. I just hope it doesn't go through seals / gaskets and past the rings. I've got a lot of miles on it.
 
#7 ·
With 500k on the clock, we should be asking you!! I will soon cross 200k.

I am a fan of ROtella T6 which until recently was 5W40. More often than not, the T6 is becoming available in 15W40 only, so I am switching to that.

One of the things that hold me back from a new truck is I can‘t do what I like with a truck I’m making payments on. Too afraid to scratch my new toy driving it down a dirt trail.
 
#8 ·
I think you’ll see positive results switching. I would stay away from the motorcraft oils though, they consistently test at the lower end of the spectrum. The old leaking after switching tales were from the older formulations of synthetics that’s no longer the case. My old 6.0 and my wife’s tdi Jetta are at over 500k miles on T6 and no issues to speak of.
 
#11 ·
I always used 5W40 in my 6.0 to cure cold loping idle. Never had an issue with oil analysis. I use Rotella T6 in my 6.7 since first oil change. Clean oil samples. I swear by synthetic especially in colder climates. They are superior in every way and don't cost that much more than regular oils. You can usually find it in 2.5 gal jugs for around $46-$50.