Ford Powerstroke Diesel Forum banner

6.0 oil analysis on Rotella T-5 10w-30. You will probably like this.

1 reading
307K views 878 replies 172 participants last post by  Brick mason  
#1 · (Edited)
Image


I was asked what kind of symptoms my truck had BEFORE I switched to this oil. Here it is. There is also a small little paragraph at the bottom of this edit that shows how I'm maintaining my injectors.

Another thing to mention. Some people have had their stiction fixed almost immediately. Others it took almost 500 miles of driving and some others less. What I am saying is that after you switch to this oil, you must DRIVE the truck. Imagine it this way. When you polish metal that is need of a polish, it just doesn't MAGICALLY shine. Sometimes you have to work it with a little elbow grease and sometimes you really have to get into it. Imagine the T5 is metal polish and your engine needs to be polished. Some engines will be quick while others will need a buffing wheel. Give the oil a chance to get in there and clean out the old crud before stating it doesn't work.

----------------------------

Here is a list of people who swapped to this oil and their thoughts/opinions. There are MANY users so this is just a small list.

1. Obsidian -------(03) Fixed stiction quickly
2. twhetten ------(04) Fixed stiction
3. Baddestt ------(04) Fixed stiction
4. Bwheelz51 -----(03) Fixed stiction
5. WLDHRSE ------(06) claims it runs smoother and more quiet.
6. Nylyon ---------(03) runs smoother and more quiet.
7. craftkr ---------(03) starts quicker and runs more quiet.
7a. craftkr---------(05) Added Rev-X and solved his stiction.
8. PAF350 --------(06) Starts quicker and runs more quiet.
9. F8LWS6 --------(03) Engine sounds "happier"
10. skid326 -------(05) More quiet.
11. troid123-------(06) Solved his stiction after 50 miles.
12. snow4664-----(06) nothing stated.
13. lacooks--------(??) Added sea-foam and it fixed stiction in 2 days.
14. ClayHenry------(??) Smoothed cold starts after awhile
15. roary ---------(03) better starts and smoother running
16. ironmover------(04) smoother starts and quieter
17. mah77---------(06)
18. lubbockguy1979 (06)
19. Chango---------(??)
20. rockbound------(03)
20a. rockbound's bud(04)
21. Jorlee----------(06)

----------------------------


Before I used this oil, on cold morning my truck would be a total PITA to start. When it did start, I would have to let it sit and idle for 5-10 minutes before leaving. I actually had another set of keys made so that I could get up, go to the truck, start the truck, lock the doors and go back inside to get ready for work.

When it did start it would run REALLY REALLY rough. The entire truck would shake. It would sound absolutely HORRIBLE and on a few occasions it would stall and I'd have to start it again. Sometimes even after that it would again stall. I never had her stall on me more than twice though. When it got warm enough for me to drive, she would have minimal power and the power would gradually grow as the engine warmed up. Then it was smooth sailing.

Now this isn't just on cold temp mornings, this also happened when it was fairly warm outside (80ish) and it would STILL do this though not as bad.

Once I change my oil I never had this problem again. And that is all I did. No Rev-X or other types of oil additives.

Things I do to ensure that my injectors stay clean is check my oil every so often for signs of metal or just the quality of the oil and the quantity. I also run Cetane booster through every tank. I keep the oil filter and the fuel filters changed also.

------------------------------------------

I will continue to use this and I will increase my interval to 7500 for the next oil change.

I love this oil and it solved my cold start rough idle. It also likely increased my hp/tq by a small amount due to the decreased friction in the engine and increased lubrication. I can't state for sure on how much MPG I gained by switching to this oil but I routinely get about 23-24mpg on the interstate at 74mph indicated (about 70-71mph on the GPS). I average between 15-18mpg around town.

I apologize for the crappy quality but photobucket dulls down the picture size so I had to do the best I could. I am willing to upload it to another site. I have a high quality picture saved to my computer.

The oil report reads as follows:
"Brandon, the PSD that powers your F-250 is wearing nicely at 123.337 miles. Our universal analysis shows typical wear from the 6.0L after an oil run of ~5,000 miles. Your oil was run just a little longer than that but we think you could easily push up to 7,500 miles on your next fill. The oil was in good shape physically and contained no harmful contaminants. The TBN was still fairly strong at 4.9 so there was still a bit of active additive left. 1.0 is a low TBN. You've clearly been taking good care of this engine. We see no signs of any problems developing."

Mileage on oil: 5,500
Mileage on unit: 123,337
Sample Date: 6/11/10
Make up oil added: 0qts

---------------------------------------------------Unit/Location average---------------------------Universal average
Aluminum:-------3----------------------------------------------3-------------------------------------------3
Chromium:-------1----------------------------------------------1-------------------------------------------1
Iron:-----------14---------------------------------------------14------------------------------------------21
Copper:---------2----------------------------------------------2--------------------------------------------3
Lead:-----------3----------------------------------------------3--------------------------------------------3
Tin:-------------3----------------------------------------------3-------------------------------------------1
Molybdenum:----1----------------------------------------------1------------------------------------------34
Nickel:----------1----------------------------------------------1-------------------------------------------0
Manganese:-----0----------------------------------------------0-------------------------------------------0
Silver:----------0----------------------------------------------0--------------------------------------------0
Titanium:-------0----------------------------------------------0--------------------------------------------0
Potassium:------4----------------------------------------------4--------------------------------------------4
Boron:---------14---------------------------------------------14-------------------------------------------49
Silicon:----------5----------------------------------------------5-------------------------------------------12
Sodium:---------3----------------------------------------------3--------------------------------------------4
Calcium:-----2473-------------------------------------------2473-----------------------------------------2827
Magnesium:-----9-----------------------------------------------9------------------------------------------135
Phosphorus:-1132--------------------------------------------1132-----------------------------------------1115
Zinc:--------1298--------------------------------------------1298-----------------------------------------1292
Barium:---------0------------------------------------------------0--------------------------------------------2

I believe that my truck is one in a few as the unit/location averages are exactly what I have which tells me, there is nothing else to average it against.

Properties:

-------------------------------------------------Values should be...
SUS Viscosity at 210ÂşF:------61.2----------------------59-65
cSi Viscosity at 100ÂşC:-------10.57--------------------9.9-11.9
Flashpoint in ÂşF:--------------405--------------------->400
Fuel %:----------------------<0.5--------------------<2.0
Antifreeze %:------------------0-----------------------0
Water %:----------------------0---------------------<0.1
Insolubles:---------------------0.1-------------------<0.6
TBN:--------------------------4.9---------------------n/a
TAN:--------------------------n/a--------------------n/a
ISO Code:---------------------n/a--------------------n/a

According to a SUS and cSi viscosity chart, my oil is damn near perfect at 30wt so my 6.0 did not shear my oil at all. The TBN is still fairly high at 4.9 so I can pull more miles out of my oil and I will.

I beat on my truck normally and just blow everything out from time to time. I burned little/no oil during my 5,500 miles. I didn't add a drop between changes and I pulled out right at 15qts. I filled a 15qt container to the brim when I changed my oil.

This is REALLY good news. :thumb:

Ford states in the manual that 10w-30 oil can be used but it is not recommended for trucks that tow a lot. I don't. However, since the 6.0 shears down the 40wt to 30wt anyway, I am curious to see a truck towing with this oil and getting the report.

Shell Rotella T5 10w-30 is in fact a DIESEL OIL. It has the CJ-4 Spec code on the back and from the information I've gathered is a really good spec to have.

If you have any questions/thoughts/concerns, please either post here or PM me.

Also if you change your oil to this and it cures a problem your truck has had, please post up here or let me know in some way. I'm trying to see just how many different problems this oil is helping to fix.

--------------------------------------------------------

Below is RoadRunner 's scan of his oil. Notice his distance traveled! Also to make sure...


THIS IS ON JOHN DEERE OIL.


Too bad he didn't get a TBN report to see how much additive was left.

oilscan through john deere
oil - 10w-30 plus 50 john deere CI-4
7,424 miles on sample
104,xxx total miles on truck
no make-up oil added

iron..........................................11
chromium..................................<1
nickel.......................................<1
aluminum....................................1
lead...........................................3
copper.......................................1
tin...........................................<1
silver.......................................<.1
titanium....................................<1
silicon....................................... 6
boron......................................170
sodium.......................................2
potassium................................<10
moly.......................................119
phos......................................1366
zinc.......................................1569
calcium..................................3992
barium....................................<10
magnesium................................16
antimony.................................<30
vanadium..................................<1
fuel% vol..................................<1
t/s% vol.................................. .5
water% vol...............................<.1
vis cs 100`c.............................10.6


Another of his reports.

Well I recieved latest oilscan this morning so I thought I would share

OILSCAN through John Deere
07 F350 6.0
John Deere plus 50 10w-30 (CI-4)
miles on sample 7,476
total miles 119,864

iron..................................11
chromium..........................<1
nickel.................................1
aluminum............................2
lead...................................2
copper...............................1
tin...................................<1
silver...............................<.1
titanium............................<1
silicon................................7
boron..............................191
sodium...............................5
potassium........................<10
molybdenum.....................129
phosphorus.....................1424
zinc...............................1648
calcium..........................4165
barium............................<10
magnesium.........................15
antimony..........................<30
vanadium...........................<1
fuel% vol...........................<1
t/s% vol......................... .5
water% vol........................<.1
vis cs 100c.......................10.5

there was no make-up oil added
the report came back acceptable and oil and filter was changed at the time of the sample, with 10w-30.
this will be my 4th consectitive run of 10w-30 and every sample has came back almost identical.

-----------------------------------------------

T5 after 8,000 MILES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Image


That's right, I was just advised to go to 10k. I think that is what the amsoil guys are runnin to. Pretty good for oil that is $11.50/gal.
 
#4 ·
And why are you running regular oil ?? 15w40 or 5w40 is for diesel 10w30 is for gasser ? this is new wtf
 
#9 ·
in my above post i stated it is CI-4, which is diesel motor oil.
almost if not all major oil companies offer a 10w-30 diesel oil, and yes its in the owners manual.
it seems some motor oil is more prone to shear in the 6.0 than others, and the 10w-30 will hardly shear at all, almost if they prefer it. when i was running 15w-40 yet, it would shear, but not out of grade like the rts did.
the two runs of rts 5w-40 sheared to 10.6 cst a mid 30wt., where the 15w-40 deere plus 50 sheared to 12.8cst after 7,500 mi, still well within 40wt. grade.
so after several uoa's i came to the conclusion why should i spend 20 bucks a gallon on the rts when after a 7,500 mi. run it was only a 30wt? now i spend 11 bucks a gallon for a 30wt. and after 7,500mi. i drain out a 30wt., with lower wear numbers, and a little bit more money in my wallet
 
#599 ·
My rundown of viscosity



I turned wrench for a good number of years, and I've got experience with all sorts of oils from my time in the Marine Corps taking care of $2 million aircraft engines, and then employing those engines to deliver hate and discontent to the $h1theads out there who wish to do our nation harm.

The SAE numbers designation breaks down the oil into viscosities at low temperature and high temperature.

Let me start by stating what lubrication engineers would like to have in an ideal, perfect, unobtainable world-- a lubricant with the viscosity of water that stays constant up to extreme temperatures. When you start an internal combustion engine, a low viscosity oil is desired... as low as one can possibly attain because the faster lubrication is delivered via the buildup of operating pressure, the less likely suddenly moving parts are going to wear through whatever lubrication film is left on surfaces from the last shut down.

So, for most gas vehicles, a 5W viscosity is adequate for cold startups and such. This brings us to the other problem engineers face-- keeping that oil thick enough to be effective up to full operating temperature (let's call it 200F for the sake of discussion). Obviously, a straight 5W viscosity oil will loose quite a bit of viscosity as it heats, and in effect become worthless as a lubricant at some point due to excessive thinning. This is where the second number comes in. In the case of a 5W-30 oil, thickening polymers engineered by dudes smarter than you or I are put into the oil, and chain together as the oil heats up, keeping the actual oil viscosity a little more consistent over a wide range of temperatures. If you were to look at a viscosity vs temperature graph for a solid weight oil, it would start at a certain viscosity and essentially decrease linearly at some rate as temperature increases. The addition of carefully engineered thickening substances tries to make this relationship more constant and the curve a little flatter. The engineering challenge for lubricant companies is that the wider the range in viscosity change, the more susceptible that product is to "breaking down," or in other words, the mechanical shearing breaks down the thickening agent to a point where it doesn't reach the number it once did when it was new. This is why all the 0W40 and 5W40 synthetics cost a bit more than your regular 5W30 and 15W40 oils.

All the German manufacturers seem to have gone to 0W40 as the recommended, American manufacturers are going to 5W20 to save a mild amount on fuel economy with an acceptable level of reduction in mechanical reliability (I still put 10W30, 5W30 and 0W30 in all these vehicles, depending on season) to comply with the goofy goddamn CAFE standards.

I do regular oil analysis on my truck through Blackstone since I bought it. I have had two samples come back supurb with Rotella T 15W40 at 5000 mi each interval. I'm running 15W40 right now, but since our power strokes have an oil-fired injection system, I'm moving to a 5W40 synthetic for the winter months as in the gas exploration business I can either leave my truck idling all day, which would make my fuel costs skyrocket, or just do the best I can to protect it with 6-10 starts a day. The thinner that oil is at 5F, the happier my engine will start without the block heater.

I hope this long-winded explanation breaks it down for y'all. Cheers.
 
#6 ·
Yes im curious to what the 10w30 was sheared to ?????? if 15w40 get sheared to 10w30
 
#10 ·
Rotella T-5 is the 10w-30 DIESEL OIL offered. It is diesel oil.

I am not quite sure on where the "sheer" is on my report and I can cut an e-mail to blackstone to help clarify any sheering, but the viscosity reported in the report above reads as follows:

SUS Viscosity @ 210ÂşF - 61.2. Values should be between 59-65.

So I'm within this range.

cSt viscosity @ 100ÂşC - 10.57. Values should be between 9.9-11.9.

I'm also within this range.

Viscosity Charts

The above link has the SUS viscosity chart. According to it, at 210ÂşF, my oil is sheered at exactly the right level of 30wt.

My cSt range is also exactly at a 30wt.

So there you have it. NO sheering whatsoever.

This does cost me a pretty penny when I change my oil. Almost $80 per oil change. However, this report will be saving me money as I will now be extending my oil changes another 2,500 miles. I am also running my engine WELL with this oil.

The owners manual states that I can use this grade of oil for what I do, which is mainly haul things occasionally and just basically use this is my own personal back/forth to/from work.

The owners manual also states that trucks that routinely haul should use 15w-40.
 
#11 ·
interesting, subscribed
 
#12 ·
Another couple of GOOD things to report with this oil.

1. I am burning absolutely ZERO oil. I drained 15qts when I drained my oil and I didn't add a single drop throughout all this time.

2. My mileage is pretty good. I got 22-23mpg on the interstate during a recent trip to Savannah, GA.

3. My average around town and back/forth to/from work mileage is 16-18mpg.

4. I had HORRIBLE stiction before I switched to this oil. I now have absolutely zero stiction and I never had to use the oil additive I see referred to on this site.

5. It's available at my wal-mart for about $16 a gallon. 4 qts = 1 gallon so $64 for 16 qts. I have 1 qt spare to keep between changes. I also buy the motorcraft filter available at my wal-mart for $18. 64+18= $82 spent. I consider this a good investment to maintain this AWESOME engine.

Shoot me any questions you may have.
 
#14 ·
The T-5 I'm using is a synthetic blend so no, it is not a full synthetic.
 
#15 ·
Whats the Ford oil? Is it a part sythetic?
 
#16 ·
definitely subscribed to this one :popcorn2:
 
#18 ·
I believe the motorcraft oil is just regular dino oil.

My truck isn't stock. But it's not heavily modified either.

K&N Cold air intake.
Deleted Cat.
Deleted muffler.
Coolant Filter.
Cat ELC coolant.
Diesel Kleen cetane booster every tank.

And a few other cosmetic mods.
 
#19 ·
Original Headgaskets BTW.
 
#21 ·
Naw man. That is waaayyyyy too big of a sig for my personal preference. It used to be there but I like the picture of my truck more. lol. It's a good pic.
 
#22 ·
Thanks for posting about the Shell Rotella T5 Diesel Oil 10w30. It is a Group II + PAO synthetic blend. It is an EXCELLENT oil for these powerstroke diesels. I have been using it since it first came out several months ago. It performs flawlessly in my 6.0 and better performance and mpg over the 15w40 and even 5w40. It virtually doesn't shear. I've got my neighbors using this oil in their 7.3 and 6.4 and they love it.

Amsoil makes a 10w30 Diesel Oil as well, full synthetic called the ACD, but its much more expensive than the T5 @ 16/gallon at walmart. You can easily run either oil for 5K miles, and likely more.

I've been tempted to try the Amsoil 10w30 next, but can't justify the price over the Shell T5.

This is a great post and should be read by everyone who has a powerstroke, because the Shell T5 10w30 makes a difference in the way these engines perform and how those injectors operate. Awesome stuff:nod:
 
#24 ·
I'll definateoy try it. I just changed oil and used Valvoline premium blue for the first time and i noticed no performance gains and still have a little sticktion going on. The valvoline was 35 bucks a gal! but i had to try it...thumbs down though. I'll use the T-5 next.
 
#32 ·
$35 a Gallon??? I got 8 gallons of Valvoline Extreme Blues Synthetic 5w40 for $169.74 shipped to my door. If you have a NAPA store close check with them. I have seen others buying it there for $24 a gallon. My local O'reilly's had the non-synthetic for $13.99 they said they could order some synthetic for $26.99.
 
#25 ·
I'm thinking about trying the Amsoil 10w30 next go round. If it is stable it should go extended. It starts with a TBN of 12 and uses no viscosity improvers to shear down. It's $10 a gallon cheaper than their 5w40 too so that right there will save me $40.
 
#843 ·
Did you try that Amsoil ACD out? I still haven't, still with the shell T5, but I think I'll hit up the amsoil ACD next oil change to see if there is any difference.
 
#26 ·
To anyone with the stiction, just change your oil RIGHT NOW to this. Let us know how it goes. Seriously, it stopped my stiction immediately.