I went with red line. That's what my parts house had. Should be good. I only did the rear for now. I may end up dumping it again soon though. It looked really dirty inside and the magnet on the plug had a literal puck stuck to it. My pinion seal is also starting to leak so I wonder if it was getting low. Good news is the gears looked really good. No adverse wear patterns at all.
Sent from my dumb smartphone