Ford Powerstroke Diesel Forum banner

late HPOP test device build

4288 Views 55 Replies 7 Participants Last post by  bismic
6
Hello Gentlemen,
I would like to build a device to test second/late generation HPOPs.
To see how they work I have started to disassemble a pump.











Can anyone tell me how these inserts are fixed in the housing? I can't hammer them in, nor can I pull them out with an impact hammer.




See less See more
41 - 56 of 56 Posts
But not in '05?
I think Jack that this principle could also be the case with the late pump. The flat friction surface on the early pump is larger than on the late pump, but the late pump has the conical connection. Due to the conical design, the power transfer is naturally greater, so the smaller friction surface on the late pump could be sufficient.

See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
What I was thinking, Hartwig, since tapers lock pretty damn tight, there was no low threshold for slippage. To have the back of the gear still be a locking member in concert with the taper and control the amount of "lock," both the gear and the shaft would have to have extremely tight tolerances; taper ratio to back flange. If the back, flat area bottoms first, the taper might not have any lock and would allow for wobble.

They may have that, but I thought the taper is the control, both locking and alignment. Maybe the piston-style pump design is expected never to lock.

Anyway, just a thought exercise.
15
In the early HPOP there are 7 pump elements, the late pump has only 4 pump elements, but these are larger.
In general, the early pump has a much more complex design than the late pump. But why the early pumps fail so often I could not see. The functional principle is a million times in all kinds of pumps in use .





























See less See more
"Stuff" I have accumulated ...................

Credit to FordDoctor, CNCFab, DieselSite (hopefully they do not mind that links to their information is copied and pasted.

Failure mechanism in the 03-04 HPOP's - and possible "fix":​
Failure areas:​
03-04.5 HPOP issues include a housing weakness (back plate wear-out) and swash plate issues (a light press fit is intended to hold the swash plate in place but apparently they can spin and cause failure). Also, there is documentation on rotating cylinder cracking. Wikipedia states that the gears were weak and cracked.​
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
That circular scar on the brass plate, in your picture, will cause the cylinder body to "lift and skate" under high pressure -- the pump will work fine at lower pressure, then fail when high pressure is asked

The end plate can rotate, this throws the pump valve timing off, decreasing or completely failing to pump
  • Like
Reactions: 2
10
Thanks for disassembling one, Hartwig. I've not gathered ones to take apart.

I tried to enlarge the valve plate images—it appears kind of another instance where good oil is imperative.

Hydro, that valve plate looks to be keyed. Can they still move, or does the key shear off? Everything there looks like many axial piston pumps. I know I've seen kits for rebuilding them, but I have no experience with how easy it is to rebuild one successfully. Obviously, we have a rebuilding issue in the aftermarket.

Wheel Tire Automotive tire Alloy wheel Tread
Automotive tire Wheel Motor vehicle Automotive lighting Rim



My understanding is there are two and maybe three different designs for these with our engines. The ones with the wear-resistant hard plate were referred to me as the "International pump", while those without were referred to as the "Ford" pump. Ford opts for cheaper, although that information is from only one source.

Mine was identified as the "International" version with the wear-resistant plate. Notice the design of the base.

Images of mine.

Gas Cylinder Auto part Machine Nut
Automotive tire Tin Audio equipment Automotive lighting Rim
Cylinder Gas Auto part Machine Metal

Gas Cylinder Auto part Machine Metal



This is a pump that was designated as the "Ford" pump. A different base mount.

Font Automotive lighting Gas Engineering Audio equipment


From that same person, again, the International pump.

Bicycle part Automotive tire Tool Nickel Carbon


There is another variation I've found, which may be an aftermarket part change or more of a tell for another version.

The rear sealing plates can be dished or flat. As shown above, my rebuild pump called "International" with a wear-resistant plate is dished.

Automotive lighting Automotive tire Drinkware Automotive design Bumper
Rim Carbon Gas Circle Electric blue


Exceeded image allowance, flat plate in next post.
See less See more
2
Automotive lighting Gas Metal Rectangle Silver



From what I've gathered, it seems like the HPOP reman supplier to Ford and International had been International Fuel Systems in Indiana, which became a division of Remy. It was then purchased by Caterpillar in 2007 at the same time CAT purchased Franklin Power Products, the company Ford and International used to reman the 6.0s. This was where my engine was rebuilt.

Font Screenshot Number Event Electric blue


Anyway, I haven't substantiated the information of different designs or if the pumps were designated for International and Ford production. The VT365 shares many components but, at the same time, has its own designed parts. It's possible Ford targeted a lower mileage life for their chassis and, therefore, would take an option for parts less robust to save money. While International, for its chassis, would opt for longer life. Just speculation.
See less See more
@TooManyToys Not the valve plate, it is keyed as you mention -- the problem is the "plug" which contains the swash plate, that is the part that is not keyed, in some / most of these pumps

Maybe that is not the best description, so here goes -- the part that contains the swash plate and rear bearing, has to be indexed to the valve plate, for the pump to work properly
this "plug" is just a press fit in the pumps I have seen -- A very poor design -- A locating pin or protrusion to lock that part would have been good

Reference Hartwig's post, the first picture -- the part the pistons are sitting in
  • Like
Reactions: 1
OK, now I understand what you were saying. The term end plate took me to my definition, and I thought that plate would not do anything, so he must mean the valve plate.

These are the terms that I used in the past, set plate rather than swashplate, but I don't work in your field.


Automotive tire Rim Font Asphalt Motor vehicle
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
10
more pics





Sensitive content, not recommended for those under 18
Show Content














See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 3
A big thanks for doing this, Hartwig.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I am thinking that many of the "bad" pumps have suffered from the swashplate holder rotating in the bore -- the location affects the timing of the pistons and valve plate > then the pumps ability to move oil. Just a simple roll pin to locate that part would be a good fix

The brass valve plate in the pictures is junk -- those scratches connecting the valve ports are a killer in this style of pump -- the higher the pressure the pump is making, the worse the lifting affect is on the plates -- this causes the whole cylinder block to lift from the valve plate and spew oil from between the cylinder and valve plate , rather than deliver out the pressure port -- when the pressure called for is reduced, or the system is shut down, than the plates will come back into contact -- and pumping will seen normal again, until high pressure is reached -- the no or low pressure again as the plates separate

I have ran into this scenario many times with the machines I work on -- a pump will flow almost to spec at lower pressures but as the max is reached the flow drops off all of a sudden -- testing with gauges and a flow meter

Not the valve plate, it is keyed as you mention -- the problem is the "plug" which contains the swash plate, that is the part that is not keyed, in some / most of these pumps

Maybe that is not the best description, so here goes -- the part that contains the swash plate and rear bearing, has to be indexed to the valve plate, for the pump to work properly
this "plug" is just a press fit in the pumps I have seen -- A very poor design -- A locating pin or protrusion to lock that part would have been good

Reference Hartwig's post, the first picture -- the part the pistons are sitting in
This was part of the conclusion from the Machinest's WorkShop magazine and, from my interpretation, the description given by FordDoctor ("a light press fit is intended to hold the swash plate in place").

A lot more of an issue than simple priming procedures (not that priming the pump isn't a good idea).

EDIT - for the record (from a thread 2 years ago):
"I am not saying that properly priming the OEM pump wouldn't increase its reliability. No doubt it would. Seen that in industry MANY times. To what extent it would help, who knows."
I am thinking that many of the "bad" pumps have suffered from the swashplate holder rotating in the bore -- the location affects the timing of the pistons and valve plate > then the pumps ability to move oil
Just a simple roll pin to locate that part would be a good fix

The brass valve plate in the pictures is junk -- those scratches connecting the valve ports are a killer in this style of pump -- the higher the pressure the pump is making, the worse the lifting affect is on the plates -- this causes the whole cylinder block to lift from the valve plate and spew oil from between the cylinder and valve plate , rather than deliver out the pressure port -- when the pressure called for is reduced, or the system is shut down, than the plates will come back into contact -- and pumping will seen normal again, until high pressure is reached -- the no or low pressure again as the plates separate

I have ran into this scenario many times with the machines I work on -- a pump will flow almost to spec at lower pressures but as the max is reached the flow drops off all of a sudden -- testing with gauges and a flow meter
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I agree. I think it's maddening there was no locking mechanism, just a friction fit.

Mark, I Never said it wasn't more of an issue than only priming. The point I have made in the past about priming these during the initial installation has to do with the scoring of the brass valve plate, a failure mode right out of the box. I'm not sure everyone fills the oil system (oil cooler reserve or dumping into the filter assembly [Pete]), so there may be a period of low lubrication. But, you always seem to dismiss that in some fashion.
A lot of good information in this thread, and it is an enjoyable read. Thanks to @Hartwig and @Hydro.

Ultimately, I wonder about the availability of re-manufactured 03/04 HPOPs that have actually had these issues addressed.

While DieselSite and CNCFab have not shared all the details of their improvements, I would suspect that they have addressed them since their reliability record seems to be very good (now that we have a significant number of years of people running them). I also suspect no other re-manufacturer has addressed them, but that is just a suspicion and an opinion.

Anyone have a recently purchased re-manufactured 03/04 Motorcraft HPOP available for testing??

I would throw $20 into a fund to purchase one for forensics just to see if anything has significantly changed in recent years of re-manufacturing.

As far as dismissing anything - that is jumping to conclusions a bit, but the LPOP fills very quickly even at low rpm.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
41 - 56 of 56 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top