You will find that the Die Hard union guys are very much against volunteers because they feel like everyone should have a paid dept. We all know that its just not possible everywhere. I am full time professional firefighter, but respect and admire the work the volunteers do. Especially since they do it for free!!
To answer the original question?
Beaumont Tx Local 399 here. There are things I love about the union. Things we would never have without the union. But there are times the union gets a little "radical" on certain issues, but thats just something you have to work with. But it is definitely better going to the city as a united group. WE have had rough times in the past with the city, but are working on building a good relationship with our city leaders. Its not always easy. I would say our biggest steps were made when we got actively involved on the politics of city management. We put alot of work into backing some strong candidates during election time. It helps to have people on the other side of the table that share your concerns. We are also trying to help our city leaders to understand that we really do want to work with them, and that are we are not the greedy bastards they all think we are. LOL