Join Date: Jun 2011
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Feedback Score: 0 reviews
did they do me wrong?
Hello, I'm new to the Forum and thank you in advance for any advice. I have a 2007 F250. 120k miles. I've only had it six or seven months but it's been well taken care of.
Recently I had a hard start issue, no warning, just got in to go and it wouldnt. Took it to a friend's shop (not diesel people) he did check for any codes and there were none. He changed the oil as he said they were really sensitive to oil quality. Charged me $200.00 clams and sent me on my way. It did start better and seemed ok. Then one day (about a week later) the truck didnt want to start again and after finally starting I commenced to drive home. As I neared my home I noticed white smoke when I decelerated I was almost home so I continued, all gauges read normal at the time. As I turned the corner on my block, the low coolant message came up and I pulled in front of my house.
Ok, sorry, I'll try to cut to the chase now. I had it towed to a diesle specialty shop who came recommended by two different friends. They took a couple days and then called to tell me that all everything looked fine but the EGR cooler and oil cooler were both in need of replacement. They tell me it'll be $2500.00 and a couple days to fix. It's my only vehicle and I use it for work every day so I told them to get it done.
A few days later, I call them and they tell me its all finished but the tech is out test driving it as we speak to make sure its ready. Then, after I call again, they tell me it now has a knock in the engine. The Tech tells me that sometimes its normal for a chunk of crystalized carbon to get in the valve and they need a little time to check it out. After a couple more days, the owner gets on and says they still dont know whats wrong but he is going to have a listen to it himself to determine what the problem is. another day or so, I have to call again and he tells me that the problem is in the head and They's like me to authorize another $2500 to take the heads off and see exactly what the problem is. He say most likely its a valve seat come loose and if thats the case, its another $175.00 to have that fixed.
This is where I start to raise an eyebrow. After contemplating the situation, I decide to have them button it up and have the dealership come get it (on a flatbed) to get a thrid party diagnosis. The shop that did the repair told me the engine was fine before they started, fine when they finished. Wasnt knocking till they got back from a check ride.
The dealer comes and gets it, calls me the next day and tells me the problem is not in the head but in the block and they think it's a bent cconnecting rod and that the engine has been hydrolocked. I almost blew coffee out my nose when I heard the news!
So, after all that, here is my question.... If a truck comes in to your shop and the customer tells you there has been white smoke, That typically means water in the system right? If thats the case, is there a procedure (after you determine the EGR cooler and oil cooler have failed) that you ensure the cylinders havent filled with coolant? The shop that fixed it (or broke it) says there is no way to know if the block filled with coolant or not. So, they asked me to pay $2500. to replace failed parts but they didnt ever say that once they did that, there was a chance they could ruin the block by starting it afterwards. Shouldnt there be a procedure for this?
I feel like they didnt do it right and damaged my engine and now, theyre backpedaling to try to place the blame on me. It had no knock when it left my house, they told me they checked it all out and the engine looked fine. They charged me to fix it, told me it was done then came back and said it had a knock and there was no telling when it got damaged.
My feeling is that they either damaged me engine through negligence or grossly misdiagnosed the problem. If they had told me that the EGR and oil cooler were bad and they would be $2500 to fix BUT, the engine might be shelled as well, I wouldnt have authorized the first repair untill I knew all the details.
Am I looking at this the right way? I dont have 12k to buy a new engine that someone else screwed up. In fact, I dont have 12k to replace an engine that I screwed up either.
What do you all think?