You would probably have to buy used to get both parts together. I bought the paint to match top part, and the lower valance new from Ford. I got the bumper brackets (new), and the chrome part used from ebay. They want your 05 vin because that would tell them exactly what body parts match your truck. Most of the parts counter guys don't understand what your doing. If you explain it to them, they will likely tell you it won't work, even though it's a very easy and straight forward swap. Just decide whether you want a chrome or paint to match bumper, and parts. I think they sell an upper bumper already painted tan if your doing a two tone. You can also order parts from a dealership that offers online discount parts, but the shipping is pretty expensive. If you know someone who works in the local dealership, you can ask them to buy the parts from you. You can get the discounted prices and save the shipping.